A theoretical review on the stemmatic method in text criticism

Name: A theoretical review on the stemmatic method in text criticism
Author: Blacksmith, Abdullah, Saylan, Nesrişah

Title	A theoretical review on the stemmatic method in text criticism
Author	Blacksmith, Abdullah, Saylan, Nesrişah
Publication Place	Firat University - Firat University
Subject	Criticism, Textual
Type	Book
Language	ara,tur
Digital	Yes
Manuscript	No
Library:	Leitir Library
Library Asset ID	ISSN: 1304-639X, EISSN: 2791-951X
Record ID	cdi_doaj_primary_oai_doaj_org_article_a6af990021b343efb0aca07ca8fc61f1
Library Location	DOAJ Directory of Open Access Journals
Notes	The stemmatic/family tree method has become a widely used method in the field of textual criticism, especially in the West. Its foundation dates back to the 16th century. dating back to the 19th century and the 19th century. This method, which largely completed its course of evolution in the years following the first half of the century, is based on the idea that there is a lineage-related relationship between manuscripts. In this article, the genealogy method, which consists of two stages: determination (recensio) and examination (examinatio), has been examined theoretically with reference to basic sources. As with every method, some criticisms have been directed to the family tree method. However, it is seen that the elements that make the method questionable are also present in other methods. Based on the emphasis on "common error", reaching a version of the text that is free from errors as much as possible, actually including all original copies in the research work, unlike other methods, presenting the aspects that are likely to be included in the text in the footnotes to the reader in the broadest and most comprehensive way, even though it makes the research activity more difficult and long-term, being usable more effectively than other methods in the critical publication of many texts, and the text being content to be based on a few copies. Features such as being more convenient in detecting and repairing some errors that cannot possibly be noticed in criticism methods will be very effective in making the genealogy method a strong alternative to other text criticism methods followed in the critical publication of classical works, especially in the field of Basic Islamic Sciences.
Detaylı Başlık	Metin tenkidinde stemmatik (soy-ağacı) yöntemi üzerine teorik bir inceleme

View in source Leitir Library Leitir Library - Historical works, archives, and periodicals search engine

Leitir Library

A theoretical review on the stemmatic method in text criticism

Author Blacksmith, Abdullah, Saylan, Nesrişah

Publication Place Firat University - Firat University

Subject Criticism, Textual

Type Book

Language ara,tur

Digital Yes

Manuscript No

Library Leitir Library

Library Asset ID ISSN: 1304-639X, EISSN: 2791-951X

Record ID cdi_doaj_primary_oai_doaj_org_article_a6af990021b343efb0aca07ca8fc61f1

Library Location DOAJ Directory of Open Access Journals

Notes The stemmatic/family tree method has become a widely used method in the field of textual criticism, especially in the West. Its foundation dates back to the 16th century. dating back to the 19th century and the 19th century. This method, which largely completed its course of evolution in the years following the first half of the century, is based on the idea that there is a lineage-related relationship between manuscripts. In this article, the genealogy method, which consists of two stages: determination (recensio) and examination (examinatio), has been examined theoretically with reference to basic sources. As with every method, some criticisms have been directed to the family tree method. However, it is seen that the elements that make the method questionable are also present in other methods. Based on the emphasis on "common error", reaching a version of the text that is free from errors as much as possible, actually including all original copies in the research work, unlike other methods, presenting the aspects that are likely to be included in the text in the footnotes to the reader in the broadest and most comprehensive way, even though it makes the research activity more difficult and long-term, being usable more effectively than other methods in the critical publication of many texts, and the text being content to be based on a few copies. Features such as being more convenient in detecting and repairing some errors that cannot possibly be noticed in criticism methods will be very effective in making the genealogy method a strong alternative to other text criticism methods followed in the critical publication of classical works, especially in the field of Basic Islamic Sciences.

Detaylı Başlık Metin tenkidinde stemmatik (soy-ağacı) yöntemi üzerine teorik bir inceleme